← Back to News

Criterion Consulting Feasibility Study Results

Following the defeat of the ad valorem referendum, Autauga County Schools contracted with Criterion Consulting to study the financial feasibility of several restructuring options. Criterion Consulting is a highly reputable firm that works with local school boards throughout the state of Alabama to improve student education. The district’s goal in commissioning the feasibility study was to provide all students with the best education possible using data-driven results based on a neutral third-party analytical study. 

The Criterion Consulting study evaluated the following options using school system, city, and county financial data, census information, housing & tax records, historical school enrollment, and student transportation data.

  • An analysis of a possible hybrid school system built on a funding partnership between the City of Prattville and Autauga County Schools.
  • An analysis of a potential city school system, including the positive and negative impacts on both the City of Prattville and Autauga County Schools.
  • A restructuring and zone modification plan utilizing current facilities with the option for construction projects. 

Hybrid Model
The hopeful hybrid educational model that was a front-runner option was the first model reviewed and ultimately struck down. The hybrid concept was projected to be the county system combined with the entire City of Prattville as it was believed that the funds generated in the Elmore County portion of Prattville could be used by Autauga County Schools.These funds are collected by the Elmore County Commission, and they voluntarily earmark a portion to the Elmore County Board of Education. Upon the return of the data, it was noted that a hybrid school system was not possible due to the inability to gain the East Prattville revenue of at least $4 million - the linchpin for this option.

City + County School Systems
Using the same data, school district administrators requested a review of how to potentially split Autauga County Schools into two separate systems: a City of Prattville school system and an Autauga County school system. Dividing the current school district into two systems would result in 60% of the current student population enrolling in a city system, leaving the remaining 40% in the county - approximately 5,344 city students and 3,415 county students. Typically, a career and technical education program remains with the county system in an educational split; however, a final determination would be a mutual decision between both entities. 

A possible city system would incur all debt within the city limits. The annual cost is approximately $1.3 million until 2029, at which time it increases to $2.3 million due to the expiration of the interest-only payments for the new PKS loan. It is estimated that a minimum reserve fund of $7.3 million should be available for a potential city system to maintain current operations. In addition, a new city system would be required to maintain a one-month operating reserve of approximately $4.6 million. Criterion recommended a start-up timeline of approximately 15 months and noted that additional taxes would be needed to establish a city system. The average city-based school system collects 21.9 mils of local funding - more than double the current allocation. 

A county school system following a split of the district would not require new taxes to maintain operations following the rightsizing of expenses after transferring 60% of students to a new possible city system. However, there are currently 700 students attending city schools that live in the county. A decision would need to be made as to which district these students would attend after a split.

Modification Plan
If the decision is to maintain Autauga County Schools in its current state (without a split of the system), a modification plan would be required to ensure long-term financial solvency. Under the current educational funding model, a large majority of state and federal funds are earmarked for specific use. Since the district currently collects the minimum amount of local revenue, it can not afford to maintain its current infrastructure. Additional funding sources will continue to be sought after to make improvements where needed. Many of the schools in Prattville require significant maintenance due to their age and the outdated nature of the facilities. The growth in the Pine Level and Marbury communities is overcrowding current facilities, and there is no option of creating a financial plan to resolve the issue. 

Despite all the data, students remain the district’s top priority. District administrators are seeking innovative funding solutions that help ease the financial burden of operating Autauga County Schools as it stands today. The goal is to develop financial partnerships with community partners that allow for the stabilization of public education. “We aren’t advocating for a split,” said Lyman Woodfin, Superintendent of Autauga County Schools.  “Rather, we needed to know the possible ramifications of a split since a large portion of the public has voiced that they would like to see it split. This study gives us the analytical data we need to move forward in the best interest of our kids.” 

Once funding is secured, deciding on a long-term facilities plan that meets the needs of all students and their communities is of utmost importance. A few of those ideas include but aren’t limited to, constricting a new Prattville High School, evaluating enrollment trends throughout the dual-feeder patterns in Prattville, and possibly constructing a new Marbury Middle School or making additions to Marbury High School and/or Pine Level Elementary School to accommodate anticipated growth in the area. 

Download a full copy of the feasibility study here >>